The artistic value of visual art is an illusion

There is a certain deception in art—in the visual arts, specifically. Perhaps painting held something truly remarkable before the invention of photography, but in the modern world, the artistic value of paintings can quite reasonably be called into question.

We go to museums, approach the paintings, gaze at them, profess admiration for the artist’s skill and genius, and then move on to the next piece. We look at the next one—for maybe thirty seconds—take a photo of it (or pose for a photo in front of it), and carry on.

Do you truly admire the painting and derive aesthetic pleasure from contemplating the artist’s work? Or do you feel only a sense of bewilderment, wondering why you even came here? Perhaps you doubt yourself? Do you suspect that you are the only one who fails to feel any delight or awe? No—you are not alone.

I find myself standing before a portrait by a renowned artist in a museum. I look at it and genuinely wonder: why should I care about the person depicted?

It is worth remembering that, at the time these works were created, modern technology did not exist, and artists—especially talented ones—were rare. Wealthy individuals wanted portraits of themselves (or their loved ones), and artists wanted to make a living. Painting was, quite simply, a way to earn money.

And it wasn’t just portraits. Artists also addressed contemporary issues—sometimes drawing criticism for doing so.
Take, for instance, Édouard Manet’s Luncheon on the Grass (Le Déjeuner sur l’herbe). Perhaps the artist intended to reproach society, suggesting that the men of that era treated women in an improper way. Or perhaps he himself held those same attitudes toward women? And why would that be so unusual? In that sense, the work served as an expression of his personal stance on social issues—though, arguably, one doesn’t need to be a master of the highest order to do that. Take, for instance, the painting “Cain” by Anton Pavlovich Losenko. Cain is depicted as an entirely ordinary man, sporting a contemporary hairstyle—much like one of us. A thought might cross your mind: could I, too, be Cain, in some sense? Banish that thought. (As it turns out, some people who visit museums don’t even know who Cain is.)

Why is Van Gogh’s “Sunflowers” so famous? Does it possess any real artistic or cultural value? The painting itself has changed over time; the colors have faded. An average person might glance at it and walk away, completely unmoved. Or perhaps Van Gogh’s works are popular simply because the artist cut off his own ear?

Why is the “Mona Lisa” so famous? It’s nothing special—just an ordinary portrait.

There is no inherent, profound greatness in the visual arts. Why do we go to museums? Everyone else goes, so we go too. We’re told that these things are meant to be admired, so we follow the crowd.

Наш сайт и партнёры, такие как яндекс-метрика, рекламная сеть яндекса и другие могут использовать cookie-файлы для наилучшего представления вам информации и нашего сайта. Продолжая использовать этот сайт, вы соглашаетесь с использованием cookie-файлов.
Принять
Отказаться